Video: The New Standard: Stopping Phantom Carriers Before They Strike | Duration: 1808s | Summary: The New Standard: Stopping Phantom Carriers Before They Strike | Chapters: Webinar Introduction (5.92s), Introducing Panel Experts (116.369995s), Combating Cargo Theft (200.72s), Evolving Fraud Landscape (575.64496s), Q&A and Insights (1033.495s), FraudWatch Product Overview (1470.2599s)
Transcript for "The New Standard: Stopping Phantom Carriers Before They Strike":
Hey there, everybody, and happy Halloween. Thank you for joining us for our webinar, the new standard, stopping ghost carriers before they strike, or as I prefer to call it freaky freight fraud Friday fraud watch webinar. We're gonna give everybody about a minute or so to join. In the meantime, go ahead and say hi in the chat. Let us know where you're joining from. And also, I would like to call attention. We do have a button on the top right of the screen that says see the full solution. If at any point you become curious enough that you wanna see a little bit more about how the sausage is made, or maybe ask some one on one questions that you're not comfortable asking in a public setting, definitely hit that button and we'll get in touch with you and answer any questions that you may have. But if at any point during the presentation, you've got any questions that you'd like answered live, go ahead and type them into the q and a section. We'll get to as many of those as we can before the segment ends. K. We're gonna continue to give people just a few more seconds, to make sure everybody has an opportunity to get to get logged on. Alright. We've got folks from Austin, Fresno, California. Happy hall Halloween indeed, David. Hello from Boot Barn. Awesome. Alright. Well, folks, I think we've, given everyone enough time to join. Once again, welcome to our webinar, the new standard stopping ghost carriers before they strike, slash freaky freight fraud Friday fraud watch edition. My name is Danny Ramon. I'm the director of intelligence and response here at Overhaul, and we're gonna have some guests joining me today. If we can have them go ahead and come on stage, we'll have them introduce themselves. But, again, my name is Danny Ramon. I'm the director of intelligence and response here at Overhaul. I handle not just, a card theft intelligence and supply chain intelligence, but also an active role in the investigations and recovery portion, post theft event. John, would you introduce yourself to the crowd, please? Sure. Thanks, Danny. So John Herzik. I'm head of supply chain for North America for Opela consumer health. Opela brings brands to the retail marketplace, like Allegra, Xyzal, Cortisone, and Delcolex. Happy to be here. Thanks for having me. Yeah. Thank you, John. Alex, you wanna go ahead and, take your turn up at that next? Sure. Absolutely. I'm Alex Vergau. I'm the sales director for Banyan Technology. Banyan Technology is a TMS provider for over the road freight moves of all modes in North America. And at the end of the day, we help shifter shippers and three p l's, optimize their freight spend and run a more efficient freight department. Awesome. Thank you very much, Alex. And, Phil, go ahead and introduce yourself to the audience at home, please. Cheers, Danny. Hey, everyone. Happy Halloween. My name is Phil McCusker. I'm the product manager at Portowatch. And, yeah, we're helping customers basically keep their cargo safe. Great to be here, and looking forward to speaking later on today. Thank you very much, Phil. Phil will be joining us a little bit later, to go over our fraud watch solution. But let's go ahead and move into the sort of fireside chat that we're gonna be having that John and Alex and myself are gonna be having. We're gonna talk a little bit about some of the challenges, the shippers, carriers, and brokers see out, you know, kind of boots on the ground intelligence as it were. And I'd like to just kind of open this question up, first off to John. You know, incidents like cargo theft that stem from double brokering, illicit double brokering specifically, are becoming more common. From your perspective, how real is this threat for shippers today? Sure. So, you you know, I I think, you know, being in ministry, you know, more years than I hear to talk about. But, it's the progression, Danny, and and, you know, seeing it from fifteen, twenty years ago to where it is today and, you know, sometimes maybe you're sitting back in your chairs thinking, oh, that that can't happen to us or I don't know how in the heck that would happen. Right? But but, you know, it's a real threat. And and I think to the point we hear talk about a lot is the technology aspect of it continues to elevate their game at a pace that we haven't seen in in a long time. It used to be a opportunity, just, you know, taking advantage of a stop or what have you. And and now it it's it's like, you know, this this phantom theft that they can strategically coordinate from anywhere. And, yeah, it's it's a big problem for us. And one again, we sat there and, I don't think that could happen to us. And that reality hits you pretty quick, when it does. So Yeah. I can I can imagine it does? How has your organize your organization responded to these threats? It so so we, you know, we have a a you know, we operate The US out of one distribution center today, which which isn't, great for this. But what what we've done is we've really stepped up our game in terms of the work we're doing upfront with our carriers and partners and things like that. And then also, you know, we're working with other providers like Overhaul to help us build out our security program to where we maybe had some weaknesses in our driver check ins and how we did that process, but then the technology aspect that's really driving a a benefit from us. And and, and and I think just really giving us a a bird's eye view of of where our freight is, at any time, but getting the selection right upfront because that's half the game is finding those carriers that that follow your rules of engagement, know the program, and and and are very, you know, secure in their drivers and who they choose to tender our loads to and bring into our facility. Yeah. Absolutely. You know, it the the the old wisdom goes trust but verify. And I've been telling folks for a long time, you've gotta switch that up and do and do verify and then trust. And, really, with the way that the criminals are going nowadays, I I think you've gotta switch it up again and do verify and then verify again. Trust is really is really a luxury we can't afford in the supply chain world anymore. But but you faced this this issue firsthand with a stolen load that was ultimately recovered. What stood out to you the most from that experience? So, you you know, it it's funny because you you you think you've taken steps to get you there. And and and again, when it happens, you you quickly realize, like, oh, there's there's one or two more steps we probably should have taken. And so we had had a couple issues, you know, going back the last couple months. And and so we stepped up our game. We engaged, with Overhaul and and did some things inside our facility and and with our carriers. But we but we left one tiny part un unmonitored. Right? And and during the week, we got it. Like, we got people in in the you know, we have people on the but if something happens on a Thursday night, Friday night, we don't have any eyes on it. So, you know, taking that step to really get in into the the monitoring, twenty four seven monitoring that we're using, you know, gives us that off hours approach, and and, you know, definitely could've, caught caught it a lot, faster than we did. But when we did recognize that this incident had taken place, you you know, the the immediate response of, you know, us and the overall network and and and their boots on the ground, to get after this. And and, you know, so we knew where it was, in a in a general area, and then we went through, you know, one or two days of watching and checking and, you know, coordinating our efforts that ultimately led to the recovery of the load, with with a couple of guests on on the on the trailer as well, some product that had made its way on through the the journey it took over the last three, four days. And and for us, while, you know, ultimately, we can't introduce that product back in the market, it's important for us to recover it, keep it off of the secondary markets and what have you, and ultimately protect the the, you know, the consumer. So Yeah. Absolutely. You know, we we learned you you gotta run the full race. You can't complete it, you know, three quarters of the lap. You got it to a full lap. Right? You know, I I I always tell folks that criminals are like water. They're gonna they're gonna go for the path of least resistance. Right? And people often assume that that means that criminals are lazy. And I tell them, like, criminals are are gonna work exactly as hard as you make them. Right? And they've got unfortunately, strategic theft and and theft by fraud, you know, provides these criminals with a couple dozen different MOs that they can mix, match, and layer depending on the security posture of their target. So if you don't cover all your bases, like you mentioned, you know, if you leave one gap, they're gonna find that gap. And if you do something less than implementing a full layered security program, say, you just patch whatever vulnerability caused your your last theft, like I mentioned, it gives them a path of escalation that they can now practice this MO that's gonna defeat that. And then if you patch that hole, they've got another path of escalation to keep following. So it's it's something to always keep your eye out for. But, But, you know, Alex, I wanna get you involved a little bit here. From your perspective, what fraud or risk challenges are your customers most worried about right now? Well, I'd say their number one concern is just how fast fraud is evolving. It seems like it's a race to to keep up on the end whether you're a three PO or a shipper. It's not just paperwork anymore. It's impersonation, double brokering, fake carriers, even, you know, cyber attacks, right, where they're they're rerouting, drivers in real time. Our customers wanna know right away who they're dealing with and if something feels off before shipment ever leaves a dock, even back at the point of booking, that's where freight fraud watches is really valuable in my opinion. And on another perspective, if you look at some of the narrative today, they say, like, things like, oh, three p l's won't exist in in the future. There's no need for a freight broker. I feel like, three p l's and freight brokerages that embrace this type of technology actually give them a a big separation from the rest of the pack and then gives them long term job security. So it's beneficial on multi levels. Yeah. Awesome. So now you've obviously seen the value in adding FraudWatch to your offering, but what's the value even before the full integration from your point of view? Well, for one, you know, we're trying to provide an end to end solution for all over the road freight. And, as we've been talking about with frauds evolving, fraud is part of the end to end solution now. So, we already help customers manage their shipments and carrier relations. Adding fraud watch brings live verification and risk data straight into that process. It takes what used to be a separate manual process that's done outside of the system or using another system into an automatic process. Now they can see all those indicators, FMCSA status, risk scores, fraud indicators, and track those in real time. That type of context builds confidence for everyone that uses our platform. And then one of the, benefits to our offering in general is just how fast you're able to book freight, and really any TMS company. So, if fraud is part of the booking process, which it is now, then being able to automate that allows our users and customers to move at the speed that they wanna move at. Yeah. Absolutely. And that that's one of the things that these criminals kind of have on the supply chain industry at large is their agility. Right? It it's something they don't have to make decisions by committee. So, you know, doing things where we can add security to our supply chains without slowing down the process is is essential. Right? I think the criminals know the criminals are great at their job, unfortunately. Right? They they know they've been doing it legitimately, and illegitimately for quite a while at this point. You know, John, though, the the one that you experienced so I think one of the things that stood out the most to me about that one is these folks crossed six states and and repowered the load under three different carriers within a twenty four hour span. And even trying to get that done legitimately is is a feat, an impressive feat at that. So, I mean, it it strikes me that these guys are are good at their job, you know, and they could be good at the at the legitimate side of of their job too if they just tend to put in that effort. But, unfortunately, they seem to be putting in that effort, for nefarious purposes. But, John, primarily you, but, Alex, also, if you wanna if you wanna, kick in any any opinions or ideas on this, for other shippers and three p l's that are worried about fraud at pickup, what do you think is the most important step they could take to protect themselves? Knowing, of course, that there is no magic bullet that's gonna solve all of your problems, there still has to be a first domino to fall, a first step to be taken. Right? Yeah. And and, you know, everybody we always talk about end to end. Right? Everybody loves it. And and and and with this process for us, the the wake up was it it really is, you know, from, you know, selecting carriers all the way through the process. So if if we're procuring our freight in a silo and and we're going after pennies and and and stuff like that and and what that translates to on the further downstream. You know, are we really winning there? Right? So so our our team is working really hard across our organization to sort of really drive this end to end process, all the way up to what we do in our facilities, how we manage our drivers in and out, and then certainly the the the, the security aspects we're we're partnering with Overhaul on to to really, really understand this marketplace through this from the start to the end, and and the minute we we they find the holes. So we we gotta keep trying to figure out what they are and anticipate them. But, you know, we really like I said earlier, we didn't put the value on the monitoring that we probably should have because we thought we were good enough from hey. They they they they work when we work. Right? But that's not the case. So they're they're a twenty four seven operation, and we need to match that in terms of having eyes on our loads and understanding what they're doing and and where it's tracking towards. So I I just think that end to end through your organization and the understanding and educating the executive level of your organization. I mean, there's been a lot of, you know, certainly in the last year or two, you see a lot more about cargo theft and but the odds that your head of marketing or head of sales are are reading those articles probably slim to none and really getting them to understand, you know, the size of this problem and now the sophistication at which they execute, in in that place. So, you know, continuing to educate internally, to to the importance of this, from start to finish. Absolutely. Alex, anything to add? Same question or another subject you want? No. That was very well said, and I would almost say I see more logistics professionals finally embracing a proactive approach versus reactive. If you look at freight spend across whatever industry, it's usually a top 10 expense on any business, sometimes top five. And the logistics department is sometimes asked to do well, not sometimes almost all the time. They're asked to do an impossible task. We need this to operate more efficiently, and you need to drive cost down. You also need to minimize risk and increase service, and you need to do it year over year. Otherwise, we're gonna look for somebody else to do these jobs. So, a lot of times, I I sit down with logistics departments that are aware of these types of issues, and they have a hard time internally selling them up the ladder to executive leadership teams because they just don't understand how hard it is to stop, fraud and cargo theft. So I empathize with the the the lifetime transportation managers and logistics professionals, and I think that the market and, the shippers and three p l's were finally starting to realize, like, partially because cargo thefts got so bad in the last few years that if we don't take a proactive approach and invest in this, then it it at the end of the day, it's a reflection on us, not just you can't just point your fingers at the criminals anymore and say, oh, well, now you gotta look at yourself and figure out how to solve that problem. Yeah. Absolutely. Great points, Alex. Thank you very much. So we're gonna get to the q and a section. I wanna answer as many questions as we can before we bring Phil up, to go over fraud watch. So I'll go through some questions. John, Alex, if you have anything to add, please, by all means, feel free to chime in. But the first question we have here and if and if anyone, watching has any questions, please feel free to add them to the q and a section. You can ask anonymously. And again, if you wanna ask something a little bit more in-depth or or get into the, you know, the behind the scenes of how the sausage is made a little bit more, hit that see the full solution button. We'll schedule a one on one and we'd be able to show you a little bit more than we can show you on a on a semi public forum like this. But what's the biggest mindset shift logistics teams need to make in 2025? And I assume also going into 2026. For me, I think it's it's you have to operate from the assumption that you are currently being targeted for cargo theft. The game has changed in terms of what is a profitable target for the cargo thieves. It's no longer just a cost dense item. What they're really going for is is what's gonna fly off the shelves the quickest that and that allows them to be in possession of the evidence for less amount of time and liquidate their cargo into cash as quickly as possible. So so operating as though proactively you are with the assumption that you are being targeted for cargo theft, I think is the only way to keep yourself as secure as possible. There's nothing that is perfectly secure in this world, and unfortunately, this is kind of the same game as as as, you know, running with a group of your friends from a bear. You don't need to be the fastest of your friends. You just need to be not the slowest. Right? It's it's, it's about not being the low hanging fruit. John or Alex, I don't know if you guys have anything to add on that. Yeah. I I just think we we we can't get comfortable. Right? I mean, the the minute we think we got there, we were we're not. And, you know, we always we've all grown up doing fire drills and tornado drills and and things like that. But but to do the drill, you know, and and and sort of the reality of it happening and how quick that response needs to be to really dictate how quick you can get it back or your odds of getting it back. Right? And, you know, we we went at a speed, certainly, with the help and and and push up of Overhaul of this, this, this, and getting the right people in their law enforcement connect group. And, I mean, it it's just something you wouldn't imagine, to get to move that fast to recover. You know, it it was it was something. So I guess, can't stay comfortable and then really know what you gotta do in the event it happens because you gotta respond quickly. Yeah. Absolutely. You know, our our senior law enforcement liaison, John Cannon, likes to say dig your well before you're thirsty. Right? You don't wanna be making friends with law enforcement at 03:00 in the morning when you're calling them for a stolen load. You want them to know who you are before they pick up the call. Just as an example, you know, on the on the recovery side, but it applies to all things when you're talking about carrier verification and vetting as well. Right? Let's see here. Does having IdentiScan or other verification systems for validation of driver's licenses having any weight in deterrence or prevention of cargo theft? Sometimes. And here here's the thing. Right? When I mentioned you have to have a full layered security program, an IDETRA scan or a driver's license scanner, real ID scanner is one of those layers. But there is no magic bullet that's gonna stop everything. Right? Because there are certain MOs, and this is what I talk about when I talk about that path of escalation. That method will stop people with fake IDs and fake driver's licenses from showing up at your shipping location, and they will then transfer to the MO of double brokering. They will broker a legitimate carrier who has nothing to hide to show up to your shipping location and uplift that shipment. When you take pictures and scan driver's licenses and ask for signatures, and all sorts of other things, the driver is gonna be fully compliant because he has nothing to hide because he has no idea he's involved in the theft scheme. So again, yes. Use it. I'm I'm not saying don't use them. I'm not saying that they're useless. You have to use it because if you go the other route and and you verify everything else except for that, then you're gonna end up getting drivers that do have fake IDs and driver's licenses coming into your, into your locations. The the problem with these networks, folks, is that they have completely legitimate arms of their organizations that perform no other function other than intelligence gathering, which means that they're performing fully legitimate shipments. They're getting on to trusted carrier lists, and they're copying the paperwork packets. They are letting their accomplices know what the drop off procedures are, what the signature of the dock end looks like, who's gonna sign off on a proof of delivery. You know, these folks know the systems that they're working within very, very well, which is why I always advocate for a full layered security program that that covers all known, vulnerabilities. And that's not the same for everybody. That's gonna be different depending on what your supply chain looks like. Let me see here. So what are early warning signs that logistics teams should look out for? I mean, there's there's all sorts of red flags at origin. Right? One of the big ones that is a pet peeve of mine is look at the back of the trailer. If there's any rivets that have been replaced with nuts and bolts, please don't load it. The every trailer and container that comes off of a factory line on this planet, is completely equipped with rivets. No nuts or bolts. Primarily, you see them on the on the seal hasp, but it can be on any part of a hardware on the back of the trailer door. They're replaced with nuts and bolts. What it allows them to do is open the trailer door without disturbing the seal. They use this and then this goes into some of the other, you know, early warning signs you can see a fraud if you have visibility into your supply chain. Right? You need to be able to to see these early warning signs if you're gonna act on them, and one of those is illicit double loading. A lot of times, folks will use this as penetration testing. Right? They will double load, insert more cargo on onto an LTL truckload, take it across the country, and then they're charging twice for that trip. It's a minor benefit for them, but if they don't get any pushback, if they don't get any follow-up, if nobody calls them to say, hey. Why did you open this load when you weren't supposed to? Then they know that there's no additional security on there and they can continue to push the envelope. Usually, it'll it'll progress to a couple of pieces will be missing, something that could be misattributed to inventory control or inventory errors. And then it may escalate to a pallet or two, and then it may escalate to half the load or more. We can definitely see that type of thing happen. But, folks, I don't wanna take up too much of this time with the q and a. Again, if we if you have a question we didn't get to, please hit that see see the full solution button, and we will be in touch. But I wanna welcome Phil McCusker back on stage. He's gonna give us a run through of the solution. And and welcome, Phil. We'll, the rest of us will be backstage. If anyone has any questions, put them into the q and a section. We'll try and answer them by text. Thanks, Danny. Hey, everyone. So given the recent growth and how widespread carrier fraud is in The US right now, we wanna take the last five minutes to give you an overview of how our Overhaul are responding with some of our new product offerings. So at a high level, our goal is to prevent major incidents, things like full thefts, pilfridges, and legal and financial risks before shipments even leave their origin points in The US. When a full load is stolen, the total loss including replacement and recovery can reach four to six times the load value. Our focus is to prevent those high impact events in a way that's both practical and adaptable across diverse on-site conditions. The risk that FraudWatch that the risks that FraudWatch sells for, as you can see in the image below, include high risk carrier and driver assignments, carrier and driver impersonation, unauthorised double brokering and altered, like, bill of lading documents. When it comes to carriers, we screen thousands of data points for signs of criminal activity, lack of legal authority, poor operational reliability, or missing insurance. For drivers, we check for criminal activity, reliability issues, and verify their identities directly from the driver's licenses. Based on these findings, FraudWatch assigns a risk score to every US carrier and driver from one to a 100 so you can instantly know how risky they are at a glance. Excuse me. So at a high level, let's take a look at how these risk scores can be used across all key stages of your operations with the ultimate goal of reducing fraud and and minimizing loss. So starting with the network pre vetting column, this step is crucial as it ensures you're only working with well vetted low risk carriers that you can trust. FraudWatch helps you answers answer questions during pre vetting such as, what is the help of my network overall right now? Who are the riskiest carriers, drivers, and why? Are we trending in the right direction? Beyond price, how risky are new carriers that we're considering working with from a security, legal, and operational perspective? Understanding why carriers why carriers are risky then informs actions that you can take based on your risk tolerance. Within FraudWatch, there are several actions you can take to reduce score. Replacing high risk carriers with low risk alternatives and categorizing carriers and drivers as trusted and unauthorized, which instructs current staff to allow or reject these actors when assigned to Overhaul shipments. Once your network is pre vetted and set up, FraudWatch then moves into a continual monitoring mode, proactively surfacing new risks as they emerge whether from newly traded carriers or as risk scores change over time. Moving to the second column, shipment creation. Despite best efforts during pre bedding, this first stage verification generates warnings for high risk carriers or drivers as planned to be used for upcoming Overhaul shipments. For example, no shipments get created at the shipment's origin locating location using the Shipment Connect mobile app. And as users assign carriers or drivers, the system issues a warning if the risk score exceeds your specific threshold. If users then save their shipments with high risk assignments, Overhaul can notify supervisors and teams back at base who can intervene by exception from there. As you can see in the third column, the second stage of the verification process starts once once the driver physically arrives on-site to go through the pre departure checkout process. In The US, roughly one in ten shipments experience unexpected double brokering, meaning the carrier or driver aren't the ones you're originally planning. So at this stage, firstly, verifying identity or confirming that the carrier and driver are who they claim to be. If a driver's license is fake, for example, or if the carrier doesn't match your records, then those are immediate red flags for elevated risk. Secondly, identifying critical risks across the carrier, the drivers, the vehicle, and the BOL, all completed within as little as fifteen minutes before the load even leaves the site. Moving on to the fourth column, if risks are found, which FraudWatch can be configured in two different ways. Option one is to let on-site Shipman Connect users take action directly or option two is to write the review and decision making process to a group of people off-site. Being able to make a decision remotely gives you more control over scenarios where, for example, shipments are created by three PLs or other external partners where your risk managers can ensure the decision meets your specific risk tolerances and SOPs. So instead, when at least one risk is identified, approvers can receive a notification, review the risks, and make a quick decision to either allow or reject departure. Once the decision is made, Shipment Connect users are then instructed on what they should do next based on, like, based on your specific instructions. So if departure was rejected, for example, Shipment Connect could instruct users to cancel the load, begin unloading, and rebook with a with a safer carrier. Worst case scenario, if the shipment departs departs before a decision was made or if it departs after it was rejected, FraudWatch reports immediately so that the driver can be recalled back to origin before it's too late. Finally, once the shipment arrives at its destination, a receiver can scan a QR code, view a secure BOL document to help mitigate against pilferage. So that's everything we've got in store for you today. Thank you everyone for joining and thanks for our panel for sharing their experience with fraud and strategic cargo theft. If If you'd like to learn more about FraudWatch Secure BOL or driver's license verification or if you're interested in free trial, then please feel free to reach please please feel free to reach out to Overhaul for a demo. Thanks, everyone, again. Happy Halloween, and hope you hope to see you in the next webinar in the near future. Thanks, everyone. Bye bye.